Woman Fractures Arm in Arm Wrestling at Wedding Banquet, Compensation Claim Dismissed
Key facts
- Woman Fractures Arm in Arm Wrestling at Wedding Banquet, Compensation Claim Dismissed
- A woman who fractured her arm during an arm wrestling match at a wedding banquet sought compensation, but her claim was dismissed by both the first and second instances of court, which held that she should have assessed the risks herself. The court found no negligence liability in the arm wrestling incident.
- Source: PR Times
- Date: May 4, 2026
Direct answer
A woman who fractured her arm during an arm wrestling match at a wedding banquet sought compensation, but her claim was dismissed by both the first and second instances of court, which held that she should have assessed the risks herself. The court found no negligence liability in the arm wrestling incident.
- Citation
- Woman Fractures Arm in Arm Wrestling at Wedding Banquet, Compensation Claim Dismissed (May 4, 2026), PR Times
- Source
- PR Times
- Date
- May 4, 2026
A woman who fractured her arm during an arm wrestling match at a wedding banquet sought compensation, but her claim was dismissed by both the first and second instances of court, which held that she should have assessed the risks herself. The court found no negligence liability in the arm wrestling incident.
📋 Article Processing Timeline
- 📰 Published: May 4, 2026 at 18:22
- 🔍 Collected: May 4, 2026 at 18:31 (9 min after Published)
- 🤖 AI Analyzed: May 4, 2026 at 18:37 (5 min after Collected)
The judgment stated that in 2024, Ms. Chen attended a friend's wedding in Taichung. During the banquet, she went on stage to catch the bouquet and participated in an arm wrestling match. When Ms. Chen and Ms. Chuang arm-wrestled, Ms. Chen's arm was pressed and fractured, resulting in a displaced fracture of the distal humerus on her right side accompanied by radial nerve injury.
Ms. Chen stated that after her injury, she needed rest and dedicated care, and suffered psychological distress. She sought compensation of over NT$870,000 from Ms. Chuang, including medical expenses, transportation fees, lost wages, and emotional damages.
Ms. Chuang pointed out that Ms. Chen had been a physical therapist for 7 years and should have known the risks of strains and ligament sprains in arm wrestling. Ms. Chen's agreement to participate indicated that both parties acknowledged and accepted the risks of the competition, making the claim for compensation unfounded.
The judge believed that, based on common experience, arm wrestling could cause muscle and tendon strains, tears, or even fractures. Ms. Chen, as an adult of normal intellect, should have assessed the risks of participating in the competition herself. After reviewing the video of the incident, it was found that Ms. Chuang had only used a normal posture to arm-wrestle Ms. Chen and won, making it difficult to conclude that Ms. Chuang had intentionally or negligently caused Ms. Chen's injury. Therefore, no negligent tort liability was established, and the claim was dismissed. (Editor: Chang Ya-ching)1150504
FAQ
What are the key facts in this article?
A woman who fractured her arm during an arm wrestling match at a wedding banquet sought compensation, but her claim was dismissed by both the first and second instances of court, which held that she should have assessed the risks herself. The court found no negligence liability in the arm wrestling incident.
What is the direct answer?
A woman who fractured her arm during an arm wrestling match at a wedding banquet sought compensation, but her claim was dismissed by both the first and second instances of court, which held that she should have assessed the risks herself. The court found no negligence liability in the arm wrestling incident.
What is the source and date?
PR Times: https://www.cna.com.tw/news/asoc/202605040241.aspx | May 4, 2026